Free tool · Runs in your browser
Fraud vendor scorecard and RFP builder
Decide what matters before you sit through a demo. Tick the fraud use cases you need, weight ten evaluation areas from 0 to 5, then score up to three vendors side by side. You also get a list of RFP questions built from your weights, each one asking for evidence such as a blind test on your own data.
Everything is worked out in your browser. Nothing you type is sent or stored. The downloads are built on your device. The link button only builds an address that carries your choices.
How this is calculated
Each of the ten areas gets a weight from 0 to 5. The weights are turned into shares that add up to 100 percent, so only the proportions matter: weighting every area 3 gives the same result as weighting every area 5. Scores run from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong). A weight of 0 leaves the area out of the totals and out of the question list.
weight_i = your weight for area i, from 0 to 5
w_i = weight_i / sum of all weights
total = sum of ( w_i x score_i ), on a scale of 1 to 5
missing score: the area is not answered
it is left out of the sum
the total is divided by the weight answered
the table shows the share of weight covered
Every weight at 0 is refused, because there would be nothing to compare. A score outside 1 to 5, or text that is not a number, is flagged and that vendor’s total is not shown until it is fixed. A total marked partial covers only some of the weight, so compare totals only when they cover the same areas.
How the question list is chosen
The tool holds a fixed bank of reviewed questions. Each one belongs to one evaluation area and is tagged with the use cases it applies to, or with all of them. A question is included when its area has a weight above 0 and either you ticked no use case or the question applies to one you ticked or to every use case. Areas are listed from the highest weight to the lowest, and the questions inside an area keep the order of the bank.
Most questions ask for something a brochure cannot supply: a blind test on your own labelled data, a redacted decision record, an incident report, a list of everything you would export when you leave. Keep the exit questions even if you drop others. They get harder to negotiate once the integration is live.
Frequently asked questions
Why set the weights before looking at any vendor?
Because weights chosen after a demo drift toward whatever the best demo showed. Decide what matters to your fraud losses and your team first, write it down, and then score every vendor against the same list.
What does a partial total mean?
You have not typed a score for every area that carries weight. The total then covers only the areas you scored, re-scaled to the 1 to 5 range, and the table shows how much of the weight it covers. Compare two totals only when they cover the same areas.
Does the tool send my choices anywhere?
No. The weights, scores and questions are worked out in your browser, and the downloads are built there too. The copy link button puts your choices in the page address so you can share them, and nothing else.
Can I send the questions to vendors as they are?
Yes. The list is a starting point written to ask for evidence: a test on your own data, a record, a document. Fill in your own volumes and periods where a question says so, remove what you do not need, and keep the questions about leaving the vendor, because they are the hardest to ask later.
Can I put the tool on my own site?
Yes. Copy the embed code on this page. The embedded version keeps one credit link back to this page.
Go deeper
- Fraud vendor comparison: how to read a comparison by situation and test any option yourself.
- Fraud vendor exit plan: how much fraud you would still catch if your vendor went away.
- Shadow test: test your finalists side by side on your own traffic, with no change to production.
- Shadow test sample size calculator: how many fraud cases a side by side test needs.